Raiders of the Lost Cocktails


So many secrets have been lost.

At the dawn of (cocktail) time, great masters (like Jerry Thomas and Harry Johnson) emerged. These giants of the earth were able to wrest secrets from the primordial elements (like gin and brandy and bitters and ice), and from them craft potions of eldritch potency. In their wisdom, these masters recorded their secrets in tomes of lore (like The Bartender’s Guide, or How to Mix All Kinds of Plain and Fancy Drinks and New and Improved Bartender’s Manual, or How To Mix Drinks of the Present Style). Acolytes, hungry for knowledge, came to study at the feet of the masters, and in turn added their portion to the growing body of lore, and recorded their discoveries in similar fashion, and each grew in power and knowledge.

Then came the dark times (Prohibition).

The masterful potions were deemed occult and pernicious, and of the Devil, and the mages were forced underground, or else to flee into distant lands. Many strove to keep the old lore alive, and some (like Frank Meier) were even able to fan the flickering flame into new sparks of knowledge.

In time (1933), the forces of darkness were defeated, and the mages were allowed to return. But, much had been lost. The old tomes of lore had been lost or discarded, and the masters found themselves without honor in their own land. Their task was left to a new generation of potion makers, who strove to rebuild the old craft from what remained. In the face of all challenges, they triumphed, and ushered in a new Golden Age of the potion maker’s art. They, too, chose books and journals as the repository of their lore.

And then, the dark times returned, though this time the enemy came from within (pre-made drinks, chemical mixers, all the ill-gotten spawn of disco and and shag carpet). Again the potion master’s art was degraded and diminished, and the craft withered. Again, the tomes of lore were lost (i.e., they went out of print).

Still… through the drought, the people thirsted for the true potions… and a third generation of potion masters came forth (Ted Haigh, Robert Hess, Gary Regan, Dale DeGroff, et alia). Together, they began to rebuild the ancient craft.

Their work continues, but it is not done.

And that’s where you come in…

While we are certain there are great new cocktails yet to be discovered, we are equally certain there are great old cocktails that have been lost to the vagaries of time and chance. Some have been recovered by the new masters, but many have not. They are out there, in books and magazines, but they are at risk…

Accordingly, TSW is proud to announce a new monthly reader participation feature: Raiders of the Lost Cocktails.

The idea is simple: find a published cocktail that is not well known today, but should be.

The rules are pretty simple too:

  • Each month, the TSW staff (i.e., the editors and regularly contributing authors) will select a cocktail ingredient, which is accessible but not currently in vogue.
  • Each month, readers are invited and challenged to scour all published sources (old books, new books, red books, blue books… plus magazines, databases, matchbook covers) to find worthy cocktails that use this ingredient, and potentially merit revival and rediscovery.
  • Entries must be previously published recipes, and include recipe, source, author, and when possible date of publication.
  • Recipes don’t have to be unique to that publication.
  • Entries will be judged on overall quality and appeal.
  • Preference will be extended toward recipes which use relatively common ingredients, thus allowing this recipe to be prepared at a wider majority of bars.
  • Preference will be extended toward recipes which are “simpler” in nature (i.e., fewer ingredients without a complicated or burdensome construction)

The winner will be chosen by consensus judgment of the TSW staff.

Prizes are modest. The winner will be given the opportunity to choose the next month’s spirit, and (if desired), a guest spot in an upcoming TSW article (as either author or subject).

So…

The rules and task are simple, but tough, and the prize is slim. If you’re in it for the money, you’re in the wrong place. But, if you’re in it for the craft — if you want to take up a place in cocktail lore and craft — this might be a meaningful opportunity. Consider, please, the words of Robert Hess (one of the judges): “if somebody ‘re-discovers’ a drink, it might actually start appearing in magazines and on bar menus, and imagine the ’sense of pride’ the discoverer will feel about that!”  And finally, this month’s challenge spirit:

Strega.

Your challenge: Through research, find a worthy cocktail recipe requiring Strega. Publish it here, as a comment. Winners will be determined by the TSW staff.

Entries for this month’s challenge will be accepted up to October 11, 2007.

p.s. For serious contestants without access to a research library, consider http://www.vintagebook.net/about_us_uk.htm.



Information and Links

Join the fray by commenting, tracking what others have to say, or linking to it from your blog.


Other Posts
Dr. Bronner’s Electric Dream Movie: “B” and Dada
Scotch Whisky

Write a Comment

Take a moment to comment and tell us what you think. Some basic HTML is allowed for formatting.

Reader Comments

Having spent a few days at Tales of the Cocktail in the Big Easy, I saw a product called aquaICE. It seemed like the perfect ice for use in classic cocktails. Anybody know anything about this product and where I can find it? Seems like a good idea. Thanks,

Mike S.

Well, start us out easy, why don’t ya?

I’m working on it. I have an heirloom bottle of Strega to work with.

>Well, start us out easy, why don’t ya? (Thomas)

Must… bite… tongue!

Ouch!

[…] To help folks along with this month’s “Raiders of the Lost Cocktail,” I thought it only appropriate that I expand upon some details regarding this month’s challenge ingredient, Strega. […]

I started this with an advantage and a disadvantage. The advantage is that I actually have a bottle of Strega, albeit an heirloom of considerable antiquity. The disadvantage is that there are no Strega recipes in any of my old cocktail books.

So to start, I just tasted my Strega straight a few times. Given its flavors, considered that it might taste best mixed with gin or rum. I also consulted the CocktailDB.
Starting a the top of the list of Strega drinks (and with the best name, IMO), the Alberti’s Night Cocktail turned out a disappointment. As noted above, it was way too sweet, and the flavors didn’t complement well to my taste.
So I took a different tack. Recalling how the Aviation becomes the Blue Moon by trading Violette for the Maraschino, I used the same recipe (with David Embury’s 8:2:1 proportions) and substituted Strega. This works! Even my wife, who hates gin liked it right off the bat.
I don’t know if the result has a proper name already, but I won’t be so audacious as to name it myself - someone must have thought of this already. But the only recipe in CocktailDB using gin, lemon and Strega is the Strega Sour, which uses very different proportions in the ingredients. Perhaps our esteemed editor/judges will know its proper provenance.
I’m looking forward to trying the other very interesting submissions posted here. Here is my own humble contribution:

The Someone-Must-Have-Thought-Of-This-Already Cocktail
2 oz. gin
1/2 oz. lemon juice
1/4 oz. Strega
Shake vigorously with ice and strain into chilled cocktail glass. Garnish with a mint leaf.

Hi editors — it looks like some previous comments have disappeared. I posted two entries — one about 10 days ago and another a week before that, and now they’re gone. The first one I’m sure was previously approved; I saw it here when I posted the second.

That’s right, Anita did post some interesting recipes (or links to them). And I haven’t tried them yet!

Let’s try this again:

(Originally commented on this post on 10/5 with a link to: http://marriedwithdinner.com/2007/10/05/dotw-sun-witch/ )

Strega Sun Witch
1 oz Strega liqueur
3/4 oz white creme de cacao
3/4 oz orange juice
1 oz whipping cream
Orange slice, for garnish
Shake with ice, and strain into a cocktail glass. Garnish with a slice of orange.

Sun Witch a la Troiani
1 oz Strega liqueur
1/2 oz vodka
1/4 oz white creme de cacao
1/2 oz orange juice
1/2 oz lemon juice
1 oz whipping cream
vanilla extract or vanilla liqueur, to taste

Lightly whip the cream with the vanilla; set aside. Shake the remaining ingredients with ice, and strain into a cocktail glass. Top with the vanilla cream, and garnish with a light grating of orange zest.

——

(Originally commented to this post on 9/28 with a link to:
http://marriedwithdinner.com/2007/09/28/dotw-strega-nator/ )

Strega-nator
- published in “Food & Wine Cocktails 2006″ and credited to BLT Prime, New York City

2 oz Strega
1 oz fresh orange juice
1 oz fresh lime juice
2 oz chilled club soda
1 orange wedge, for garnish

Fill a cocktail shaker with ice. Add the Strega and juices, and shake well. Strain into an ice-filled rocks glass, and top with club soda. Garnish with the orange wedge.

What’s the spirit for next month?

[…] Remember last month, all those Strega concoctions we resurrected for Raiders of the Lost Cocktail? Well, it seems yours truly has been anointed the winner of said challenge, and therefore the decider of this month’s challenge ingredient. […]

[…] About a week ago, I got an email from Andrew, The Spirit World’s intrepid editor, asking me when I’d be able to send him my choice for RotLC winner. Come again? Never mind that the previous episodes’ rules had clearly stated “The winner will be chosen by consensus judgment of the TSW staff.” Andrew made it plain that the Powers That Be would not take no for an answer. I was duly deputized to act as their collective brain in matters Benedictine. [ed note: thanks for this, you lovely person, you… I didn’t even know there were rules!] […]